The 2024 Subaru Crosstrek, with a base price of $25,195 MSRP, offers greater value than the Honda HR-V, which starts at $24,600 MSRP but climbs to $26,100 with an all-wheel drive to match Subaru's standard.

Regarding performance, the Crosstrek takes the lead with its more powerful 182 horsepower engine, outshining the HR-V's 158 horsepower unit. With an EPA-rated 33 to 34 mpg for city and highway driving, the Crosstrek surpasses the HR-V's 30 to 32 mpg, making it the more efficient choice.

Although Honda beats Subaru in cargo space and roominess, Subaru's interior is still considered generous. The HR-V has 41.9 inches of front legroom and 37.7 inches of rear legroom. The Crosstrek measures 42.9 inches and 36.5 inches, respectively. Honda's cargo volume is 24.4 cubic feet, expandable to 55.1 cubic feet, while Crosstrek offers 19.9 to 54.7 cubic feet.

Both Crosstrek and HR-V have made significant strides in technology and safety. The 2024 Subaru Crosstrek impresses with dual seven-inch displays and an available 11.6-inch touchscreen. The HR-V stays competitive with a nine-inch display on higher trims. Safety-wise, Subaru introduces a new emergency steering feature, while Honda relies on its acclaimed HondaSensing suite for safety.

Despite Honda's strong offerings, the Crosstrek's cutting-edge features solidify its lead. The Subaru Crosstrek's advantages in key areas make it the winner in this showdown.